This creamy Butterfinger Pie is a fun twist on a classic peanut butter dessert. The flaky crust holds a smooth peanut butter filling and a fluffy whipped cream topping. To make it even better, it's topped with crushed Butterfinger candy. You're going to love it!

The post and recipe for Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie were originally published in August 2013. The pictures were updated in November 2018, and then the post was updated in November 2026.
Jump to:
I'm always looking for excuses to turn candy bars into desserts, and Butterfingers are one of my favorites to use. Over the years, I've made quite a few candy bar treats, but these chocolate Butterfinger cookies and mini Butterfinger cheesecakes are the ones we make the most.
So when I found an extra pie crust in the fridge and a bag of Butterfingers in the pantry, I started thinking about what else I could make. I thought a peanut butter pie with creamy layers and crunchy candy pieces sounded perfect.
The first pie disappeared before I could even get any pictures, so I had to make another one right away!
Why You'll Love This Butterfinger Pie Recipe
- A fun layered dessert. Two creamy layers make this pie a little more special than your usual peanut butter pie.
- Easy to put together. A store-bought crust keeps things simple, and the filling comes together without any extra baking.
- Crunchy candy topping. Crushed candy pieces and snack-sized bars add plenty of crunch to each slice.
Main Ingredients
This Butterfinger pie recipe uses simple ingredients to create the delicious layers. Scroll down to the recipe card for the full list and measurements.

- Refrigerated Pie Crust: I use box crust because it's an easy shortcut and gives the pie a flaky base.
- Full-Fat Cream Cheese: Provides a rich, creamy texture and helps the filling hold its shape.
- Sweetened Condensed Milk: Adds sweetness and a smooth consistency.
- Sour Cream: Gives a little tang to balance out the sweet milk.
- Creamy Peanut Butter: Adds a rich, nutty flavor and creamy texture to the first layer.
- Cool Whip: Makes the second layer light and fluffy and is used for the extra swirls on top.
- Butterfinger Candy: I like buying a bag of already-crushed pieces for the topping and another bag of bites for the finishing touch.
How To Make A Butterfinger Pie
This pie comes together in a few simple steps. It's an easy recipe with two creamy layers inside a flaky pie crust.

- Make the filling. Beat the softened cream cheese in a large bowl until creamy. Add the sweet milk and sour cream and mix again. Remove 2 cups of the mixture and set it aside.
- Add the peanut butter. Beat the peanut butter into the remaining filling. Spoon it into a cooled baked crust.
- Mix in Cool Whip. Gently fold the thawed topping into the reserved mixture. Spoon it over the peanut butter layer. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours to set.
- Decorate. Use a piping bag and a 1M tip to pipe swirls around the edge of the pie. Top each swirl with a candy bar bite. Cover the middle of the pie with crushed Butterfingers right before serving.
Pie Variations
- Use a cookie crust. If you want to turn this into a complete no bake pie, use a crunchy Oreo crust or graham cracker crust.
- Add more candy. Stir ½ cup of extra crushed candy into the peanut butter filling before spreading it in the crust.
- Make it with Nutella and Oreos. Swap the peanut butter for Nutella and top the pie with chopped cookie pieces for a chocolate hazelnut version. You can see how I made it in my Nutella Cookies and Cream Pie.

BruCrew Tips
- Prick the cold crust well. Use a fork to poke holes all over the bottom of the crust before baking. This helps prevent it from puffing up in the oven.
- Bake the crust ahead. You can bake the pie crust earlier in the day or the day before. Just make sure it's completely cool before adding the filling.
- Soften the cream cheese. Let it sit at room temperature for at least 30 minutes so it blends smoothly without lumps.
- Measure the Cool Whip. You'll need 2 cups for the fluffy layer. Measure it out from an 8-ounce container, then save the rest for decorating the top.
- Add the candy before serving. Sprinkle the crushed candy bars over the pie right before slicing to keep it crunchy.
Storage Recommendations
Cover the creamy pie tightly with plastic wrap or store it in an airtight pie container. Store it in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. The candy pieces on top will soften the longer they sit, but it will still taste delicious.

More Ways To Use Butterfingers
Do you love a recipe you tried from Inside BruCrew Life?
Please leave a 5-star ⭐️ rating and a review in the comments section below.
Recipe

Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie
The creamy and crunchy layers in this Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie will have you going back for more. It is a decadent and easy dessert to make for the holidays.
Ingredients
- 1 refrigerated Pillsbury pie crust
- 1 - 8 ounce package cream cheese, softened
- 1 - 14 ounce can sweetened condensed milk
- ¾ cup sour cream
- ¾ cup peanut butter
- 1 - 16 ounce container Cool Whip, thawed & divided
- 1 cup crushed Butterfinger bars
- 12 Butterfinger bites
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 450°F.
- Remove the pie crust from the refrigerator and let sit for 15 minutes on the counter. Gently unroll the pie crust and place in a 9 inch pie plate. Press firmly into the bottom.
- Fold the edges under and crimp. Use a fork to prick the bottom of the crust very well. Bake for 10 minutes. Cool completely.
- In a mixing bowl, beat the cream cheese. Add the sweetened condensed milk and sour cream and beat until creamy. Remove 2 cups of batter and set aside.
- Add the peanut butter to the remaining mixture and beat again. Spoon into the bottom of the cool pie crust.
- Fold 2 cups of Cool Whip into the reserved cream cheese mixture gently. Spoon on top of the peanut butter layer. Refrigerate at least 2 hours to set.
- Use a piping bag and icing tip 1M to pipe Cool Whip swirls around the edge of the pie. Top each swirl with a Butterfinger bite.
- Cover the middle of the pie with the crushed Butterfinger bars right before serving.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 12 Serving Size: 1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 586Total Fat: 31gSaturated Fat: 13gUnsaturated Fat: 18gCholesterol: 12mgSodium: 338mgCarbohydrates: 73gFiber: 3gSugar: 41gProtein: 10g
Nutrition facts are an estimate and are not guaranteed to be accurate. If you need special diet advice, please see a registered dietician.











Kayla Brynn Moore says
Currently setting in my fridge! Did a finger taste test of the fillings...oh my word...it is going to be so so good. I even did the no sugar added peanut butter bc it is what we had. Also, a shortbread pie crust (pre made of course). Can't wait!!!
Lindsay says
Can this pie be made ahead and frozen?
Jocelyn says
I have honestly never frozen this particular pie, so I'm not sure how the texture would be after thawing out. Without testing it, I can't recommend freezing it. Let me know if you give it a try.
Anthony Allen says
This will be my second time making it. I used a regular graham cracker crust and it turned out awesome! Everyone loves this pie. Great recipe, thank you for sharing
Rachael Yerkes says
This pie couldn't be more amazing! Seriously might be my new favorite ever!
Ashley F says
This is all of my favorite things in one pie! Delicious!
Liz says
What an incredible pie! One of my favorite candy is Butterfinger!
Katerina @ diethood .com says
WOW!! This is total pie perfection!! Its AHHHMAAZING!! The perfect dessert!!
Peggy says
How many crushed Butterfinger candy bars does it take to equal a cup?
Jocelyn says
I didn't count them as I crushed them. As long as you buy a bag of the fun sized bars, you will have enough. I usually crush them and put them in the measuring cup right away, so I don't end up crushing too many. Sorry that isn't as helpful as you probably wanted.
Tonia@thegunnysack says
Looks amazing! Wowza!
kristi@ishouldbemoppingthefloor says
Holy cow, girl!! This looks so delicious!
Lyuba@willcookforsmiles says
Even though I'm not a fan of Butterfingers, I really want a slice of this pie right about now! I bet it was so delicious!
Liz Fourez says
Butterfinger is one of my favorites! Definitely going to have to try this yummy pie : )
Kristen Duke says
Our summer went by much too fast too! This pie looks delicious!! We all love Butterfinger - I don't think it would last long in my house!
Mandi says
This may be a stupid question but when it says 2 cups cool whip, does that mean you actually measure out 2 cups, or do you use 2 containers of cool whip?
Jocelyn Brubaker says
There is no stupid question here. Yes, measure out 2 cups of Cool Whip 🙂 Enjoy!
Jenny@thelavendermagnolia says
Yum! I make a similar oreo/reese's cup pie, but my husband would go INSANE over this Butterfinger pie. Adding it to my list of goodies to make!
Thanks for sharing on TT&J!
Jenny
Jocelyn Brubaker says
You totally need to make this for him then!! You won't be disappointed! 😉
Tonya says
Thanks for linking up to Weekend Potluck!!! I am so excited to try this one!!!!!
Jocelyn Brubaker says
You're welcome girl! 😉 Let me know how you like it if you make it!!