Oozing red frosting and candy eyes add a spooky flair to these peanut butter Halloween Eyeballs. Serve this eye-catching treat at your next party! Your guests will get a kick out of these spooky zombie eyes on the dessert table.
Need more Halloween treats? These homemade Butterfingers and these decorated monster cookies are fun to make and eat.

Every October, our boys ask if I am going to make these spooky Halloween treats again. A few years ago, I jazzed up peanut butter balls for one party, and now my family wants them for Halloween every year.
Of course, I will never turn down an opportunity to make and eat chocolate and peanut butter treats.
My husband saw eyeball truffles on the counter and said they reminded him of the Walking Dead episode with Glenn's eyeball. He pulled up a replay and made me watch the eyeball scene.
Why You Will Love These Candy Eyes
- Delicious and fun. The zombie eyes, made with peanut butter, white chocolate, and candies, taste delicious.
- Extra spooky treat. Red gel oozing out of the candy eyes gives them that extra spooky touch.
- Eye-catching treat. When the kids and adults see it, get ready for some chuckling and grimacing at the dessert table.