This bright and beautiful Lemon Supreme Pie is the perfect way to welcome warmer weather. A creamy base, tart lemon filling, and buttery crust make it a delicious choice for spring or summer celebrations.
If you love lemon desserts, check out our lemon bars and our lemon loaf.

Lemon Supreme Pie Recipe
If sunshine had a flavor, I think it would taste like this lemon supreme pie. Each bite is bright, creamy, and filled with citrusy goodness!
I still remember my first slice of this pie at Baker’s Square in Indiana when my husband and I were dating. At the time, I wasn’t a big fan of lemon desserts, but one bite of that dreamy pie hooked me for life.
Years later, I decided to recreate that sweet-tart magic at home. I used my favorite homemade lemon pie filling, which took it to a whole new level. It's now a family favorite that we enjoy all year round.
Why I Love This Lemon Pie
- The creamy and sweet cream cheese blends just right with the tangy lemon flavor.
- A buttery, flaky pie crust gives a crisp contrast to the creamy, dreamy layers.
- The lemon filling has that perfect mix of tart and sweet flavors. It's bright and citrusy, making you want to go back for another bite every time!
- This dessert is so light and refreshing. It's the perfect treat for spring gatherings, Mother's Day brunches, or summer picnics.